BestConsumerReviews is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we earn a small affiliate commission at no additional cost to you. Learn more

Best Eye Cream

Eye Cream

Eye Cream Reviews

The eyes are the windows to the soul, so they say. Certain factors like stress, environmental pollutants, fatigue, lack of sleep, and poor nutrition can cover your “windows” with very bad curtains. Everyone wants to feel confidence in the contours and restfulness of their eye area, and specific creams for the eyes boast that they have extra-special properties for managing this delicate skin. The price of these creams run the gamut anywhere from $5 at your local drug store to $500 at Saks 5th Avenue. It’s hard to separate fact from fiction when it comes to any skin care product; especially in the profitable business of lady’s skin care. The truth is that all skin is different, and it takes quite a bit of experimenting to discover what works for your skin. Whether it’s all-natural, fragrance-free, something that your mother used to use, or the $500 cream from Saks, every woman is going to have their own personal “holy grail” eye cream that they swear by; but it might not work for you.

Most Popular Eye Cream


5/5 Product Rating

Nothing is more desired in the beauty world than a youthful eye. Day and night, every woman (and man) wants to look well-rested, healthy, and energetic. This cream from LilyAna can help your eyes when they need an extra boost. With soothing aloe, this balm manages to awaken and calm the skin surrounding eyes that are tired and stressed. LilyAna works well for both day and nighttime use, and is perfect if you need to fade those pesky signs of fatigue and aging. It is packed with vitamins that your skin needs, and is most likely deprived of. They use primarily plant-based ingredients in the formulation, as well as organic, natural oils and extracts that act like medicine underneath the skin; reviving its structure and vivacity. It should be noted that this can also be used for those little lines around the mouth, forehead, and cheek area. Thanks to the natural aloe, green tea, Oregon grape, Jojoba oil, and rose-hip, you’re going to see beautiful, natural results.

  • A natural approach to treating the eyes
  • Without mineral oil, propylene, or parabens
  • Contains Rosehip Oil, Hibiscus Extracts and Vitamins C and E
  • Can be used on other areas of the face effectively

Best Overall Eye Cream


4.7/5 Product Rating

Queen Bee is a fantastic, 100% all natural eye cream that works to brighten dark circles, fill-in fine lines, and keep wrinkles at bay around the sensitive eye area. What makes the cream so great is that there is nothing harmful in it, like the chemicals and toxins you find in some other eye creams. Queen Bee stands by the principle that if you can’t pronounce the name of an ingredient, then it’s most assuredly toxic. Even other organic and “natural” products use chemicals of one sort or another, but Queen Bee is completely free from all of that. Here is one of the very few eye creams you can find on the market that is true to what it claims to be. Under-eye puffiness and dark circles are a pain, and not only that, can be quite uncomfortable first thing in the morning. This Organic eye cream works fast to eliminate these pesky problems, all while nurturing the skin beneath your eye. It adds a bit of comfort and tranquility to your day to apply the silky cream.

  • Effective against dark circles, fine lines, puffiness, and wrinkles
  • Absolutely no carcinogenic additives or preservatives
  • Handmade in Pocono Mountains of Pennsylvania
  • 100% all natural
  • 30 ml jar

Best Budget Eye Cream


4.1/5 Product Rating

Neutrogena is one of the most trusted names in affordable and effective skin care, and their line of eye products is making some waves. The Rapid Wrinkle Repair Eye Cream uses accelerated Retinal SA for visible results in the eye area after as little as one week. The cream also contains an innovative glucose complex, a sort of catalyst that boosts and delivers the stabilized retinol with intense speed. Nobody wants to wait a month to see results from their eye cream, and Neutrogena offers the sort of instant gratification that consumers are looking for. The brand is also known for its effective use of retinol, which can be a highly strong and unstable ingredient. However, they manage to harness the power of this anti-aging gem, and deliver that power straight to the delicate under-eye region. Clinical trials have proved that this product smoothes fine lines, reduces dark circles, and prevents the formation of future wrinkles.

  • Accelerated retinol SA with glucose complex
  • Fades crow feet and dark circles
  • Brightens and re-texturizes
  • Smooths and lifts the delicate skin under the eye

Eye Cream Buying Guide

Eye Cream 1

You may have noticed a few new lines forming around your eyes, or perhaps you have dark circles. Whether you are a man or a woman, there are many different types of eye cream on the market that can help to restore the condition of the skin around the eye area and prevent further damage. These products can help to slow the effects of the natural aging process. If you’ve started your search for the best eye cream, you’ve probably noticed that there are quite a few to choose from. This guide will help you to find the one that is most likely to give you the results that you are looking for by providing a few simple tips that will give you a better idea of what you are looking for, and to narrow the list of best options for you.

Determining Your Skin Type and the Nature of the Problem

The first step is to figure out what you need to accomplish. If you have dark circles under your eyes, bags, wrinkles and fine lines, there are products that are made to reduce the appearance of them all. Next, it is important to know your skin type so you can match the product to meet your needs without creating new ones. For example, if your skin is oily, the product you choose should be more water based so it doesn’t add to the oiliness and make the condition worse. If it is dry, then a formula that nourishes and moisturizes dry skin is in order.

Types of eye cream

Eye creams are often labeled by their intended use, such as anti-aging, anti-wrinkle, dark circle remover or multi-purpose. Some products target specific issues while some are designed for broad spectrum use. The skin below the eyes is quite thin and fragile, so using the correct product is important as some moisturizers can actually cause irritation and swelling. A cream that is formulated specifically for this type of skin is the best option.

Anti-aging eye creams are formulated with ingredients that often include vitamins C and E.

These additives help to restore elasticity in the skin which is commonly lost during the aging process. They generally contain agents which firm the skin such as alpha lipolic acid or asretinol, a form or retinol. Retinol is an antioxidant which helps to rid the body of agents called free radicals, which are responsible for damage and disease. In addition, they contain moisturizing ingredients. Some also contain caffeine and/or alcohol, which help give an immediate lift to sagging skin around the eyes.

Wrinkle creams usually contain ingredients that provide protection from ultraviolet rays as these can help speed up the effects of aging on the skin. This is a preventative measure that is worth taking. In addition, they contain moisturizers to help with dry skin and firm it up.

Eye creams to lessen dark circles under the eyes generally contain vitamin K and hydoquinone as these help to lighten the skin and constrict blood vessels under the eyes. Some products that target redness and puffiness around the eyes contain caffeine as it not only gives skin a quick lift, but it also helps in soothing damaged skin cells. Bags under the eyes are reduced by including cooling agents

Hypoallergenic formulas are designed for people who have skin that is sensitive to chemicals and other ingredients that are commonly found in eye creams and other cosmetics. There are also formulations that are designed for all skin types, combination skin, oil skin and dry skin.

Woman Applying Eye Cream

What to Look for When Purchasing Eye Cream

Look for an eye cream that is based upon a formulation that matches your skin type. For example, oily skin requires a water based product. It should also be shine resistant and be easily absorbed into the skin to avoid an oily appearance. The cream should also either be a broad spectrum cream if you don’t have any major issues, but are just in the preventative stages. If you do have specific issues such as bags, wrinkles, fine lines or dark circles, then find a product that targets these specific areas.

You don’t have to break the bank in order to find a high quality eye cream that will give you the same results for less than some of the more high end products. It’s important to realize that some of the advertising amounts to a lot of hype so the price can be increased. Look for products that contain the basic ingredients to target the problem you are seeking to address.

The value of online reviews

When it comes to selecting the best eye cream, getting the opinions of other users can be of use. Everyone is an individual and may react differently to a product, but on the other hand, reading reviews will let you know what kind of experience others have had with the product, their satisfaction levels, if they would purchase it again, and if they recommend it to others. These are also good for finding out if certain products tend to cause irritation, don’t work as promised, or have failed to deliver in some other area. A good rule of thumb is to go with the majority consensus on product quality.


Finding the right eye cream can be an overwhelming task if you aren’t sure what you’re looking for. Knowing your skin type and what problems you want to work on is the best place to start. This will lessen the number of products that you will be considering. Understanding which ingredients in popular products are effective for targeting specific issues will help you to evaluate which type of cream is designed to give you the results that you are looking for.

The goal is to identify a product that is reasonably priced, contains the best ingredients to target your problem areas, and is formulated for your specific skin type. With this in mind, you are ready to begin comparing the products within this range and make your choice with more simplicity and confidence.

Back to Top